NYCRR § 3000.9(b)(1) provides that ““summary determination” may be granted “if, upon all of the papers and proofs submitted, the administrative law judge finds . . . no material and triable issue of fact is presented and that the . . . judge can, therefore, as a matter of law, issue a determination in favor of any party.” A motion for summary determination forces the Department to “lay bare”” its proof at an earlier stage. In that sense, the motion serves as a proxy for discovery. It can also provide an effective means of presenting the case to the ALJ prior to the hearing in a light most favorable to the taxpayer. Most evidence, which often consists of auditor’s testimony, his logs and other documentary evidence, is typically presented for the first time at the hearing before the ALJ in Troy.
A motion for summary judgment may eliminate the undesirable element of surprise. Surprise at hearing may derail even the strongest of cases. Once served with a motion for summary determination, the Department must respond by proving the existence of a genuine issue of triable fact. Facts not controverted in opposing papers are deemed admitted. Fair v. Stanley Fuchs, 631 N.Y.S.2d 153 (1st Dept. 1995) held that a party opposing a motion for summary judgment “must produce evidentiary proof in admissible form sufficient to require a trial of material questions of fact . . . mere conclusions, expressions of hope or unsubstantiated allegations or assertions are insufficient.” Accordingly, affirmations of counsel would be insufficient to defeat the motion. Affidavits by the auditor as well as other evidence in admissible form would seemingly be required to oppose to such a motion.
Search by Category
Natural Language Search
-
Recent Articles & Treatises
- Table of Contents for May 18 Lecture Materials April 28, 2023
- Register for Thursday, May 18 Tax Seminar in Old Westbury [click card to register] April 12, 2023
- Subscribe to Tax News & Comment April 6, 2023
- Tax News & Comment — April 2023 March 31, 2023
- Tax News & Comment — June 2019 March 4, 2023
- Tax News & Comment – April 2017 March 13, 2017
- Tax News & Comment — May 2016 May 14, 2016
- FROM WASHINGTON & ALBANY — Current Election Probabilities; Tax Plans of Trump and Clinton May 13, 2016
- FROM FEDERAL AND NYS COURTS: Recent Developments & 2015 Decisions of Note May 13, 2016
- IRS & NYS DTF MATTERS: Recent Developments & 2015 Regs. & Rulings of Note May 13, 2016
- Creating and Maintaining Flexibility in Wills and Trusts May 13, 2016
Most Popular
- Legal Basis for Seeking Abatement of New York State Tax Penalties
- Executor and Trustee Commissions Under NY EPTL
- Defeating The Right of Election in EPTL § 5-1.1-A
- Depreciation Recapture
- Letters Testamentary
- Use of Disclaimers in Pre and Post-Mortem Estate Planning
- Register Now for May 18 Breakfast Seminar in Old Westbury. 2.5 CPE Credits for CPAs in Tax. Still time to register! See Table of Contents below. Click card to register online.
- Installment Sales in Real Estate Transactions
- Valuation Discounts for LLCs
- Challenging The Account of a Fiduciary